This time, we’re exploring an iconic piece of literature by Faulkner that I read as part of my MFA program.
Faulkner uses long monologues and psychic distance to tell the story of Absalom, Absalom. As a craft, the reader ends up hearing about the story second-hand rather than directly experiencing it. Faulkner uses long monologues as family relates the story of Sutpen and Ellen to Quentin. Due to this style, we don’t relate to the characters in the action; we relate to telling the story and Quentin’s reactions to it. It is also interesting that both the Aunt and Compson know the history this well and are willing to pass on the tale. It has emotional importance to them, which is counter-balanced by Quentin’s disinterest in the story. He doesn’t quite know why he is being told this other than someone in the family knows the terrible life. Ellen’s sister is still reliving the sordid every day, which is evident in her first long monologue. But the reality is that in both tales, we hear about events of the past in non-chronological order through the sparse experiences of other people. Even when Faulkner takes us directly into the story using dialogue, it is still being related to us through another set of eyes. We hear about Ellen “must have felt” or what she “must have known,” but we don’t know because she is only present in the story as a ghost. This has the whole story taking place with a certain amount of psychic distance. Even at the end, when Quentin is much involved in the story, we’re still getting the main thrust of the story from letters to relays from Shreve. Our experience is filtered through these other characters and their feelings on the matter. No one told Faulkner about showing and not telling because that advice is soundly disregarded in this work.
The effect on the reader, I think, sets us too far away from the action of the story. Even in the moments when we are with the living characters like Quentin, Compson, or Shreve, we aren’t with them due to the long unbroken paragraphs of text that explain what is going on and those in 1909 relate to those between 1833 and 1864. The reader is experiencing this story of the South all the same. There are the people it happened to, but we aren’t talking with them. There are the people who were there and telling the story. They spend pages relating to us all this story with these exciting details ranging from clothing to the town gossip and the general zeitgeist of the story, and the reader is reading about it in a book. We are so distant from the story that it is tough to understand what is going on. In this way, the story unfolds slowly. I think part of this effect is intentional because, in the story, we have a similar experience to Quentin. However, it is hard to get invested or care about what is going on when hearing a retelling of a retelling. The marathon monologues engage the brain because the reader must be on the lookout for all those little details, and that is when the story comes to life. This is a story that comes to life in the reader’s head, and I think the psychic distance and those endless monologues contribute to that. As a storytelling style, it takes on a sort of folklore feel. It’s how stories long, long ago, and far, far away are told around a campfire, and clearly, this was intentional. Family stories are rarely straightforward like modern fiction, and this storytelling style seems to want to recreate that. In a family story, the youngest family members often hear about people they have never met and their lives, and somehow through blood, they are related to what is going on. But they are distant from it, much like we the reader. As is also typical of a family story, it takes multiple people with multiple perspectives to fully understand how all the parts fit together. I imagine that is what Quentin is doing in his head as he is reading/hearing all of this and also seeing how it impacts his own life.
I know in packet one, I was criticized for filtering and psychic distance, and I think this annotation proves two points: one, it can be challenging to get the reader invested if the story is over-filtered, and two, that it can be an effective device. I don’t think I want the reader too close to the characters in chapter one. I like that observational style, but it might be worth reviewing in future revisions.
Discover more from The Cameron Journal
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.
